Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Anthem Research Topic




Anthem Research Topic
 

 3. Is Anthem a realistic portrayal of life in a totalitarian society? Compare the fictionalized society in Anthem to a real dictatorship, past or present.
 
Having grown up in Soviet Russia herself, Ayn Rand, the author of Anthem, was influenced by her own experiences when creating the dystopian world found in her book. Born in 1905 to fairly wealthy parents, Rand grew up during a time when Russia was experiencing many struggles over power. In 1917, at only twelve years old, Rand saw a revolution take over the nation as the proletariat took control of the government. Her own family was greatly affected when her family’s business was taken away by the government, as were all other privately-owned businesses (Shmoop Editorial Team).
            The goal of the Bolsheviks, the political party that seized the government, was to create a “Vanguard of the Proletariat,” by establishing a small group from the working class as the leaders of the nation. They seized their opportunity in 1917, when the tsarist regime could not handle the pressures of World War I. Soon, tsardom fell to a revolution of the working class. The proletariat quickly took over the government and made many changes to try to make things equal for all citizens, despite class (“Revolution Comes to Russia”).
The Bolsheviks renamed themselves the Communist Party in March of 1918. Instead of having one sole ruler, they decided to establish the Council of People’s Commissars, which was a group that ran the government. Much like the World Council in Anthem, this small group of leaders made decisions for the whole nation (“Revolution Comes to Russia”).
The people in both Soviet Russia and Anthem were oppressed by their governments. They were told how to live, and even what job they would be working for their entire lives. The government simply controlled everyone’s life for what they thought would benefit “the whole”. This is shown directly in Anthem, as the people are unable to express themselves personally, only saying “we” not “I”. They are only allowed to think of the brotherhood, as one, instead of focusing on themselves. Even thinking their own thoughts is against the rules, in some cases, a sin punishable by death. Violence was used in both societies as a punishment for standing out.
Simply being different was a great sin. Rand experienced this firsthand when she was in school. She nearly got expelled from college because she was too smart, much smarter than her classmates. Equality has the exact same problem. Not only does he look different, but he is hungry for knowledge and asks many questions, something which is discouraged by his teachers when he is in school. When he is assigned his job, the Council of Vocations holds him back, giving him the job of street sweeper, for they do not want him finding out the truth (Shmoop Editorial Team).
Also, neither society really had a religion. Stalin was completely against religion and suppressed it by all means, enforcing atheism onto the people of Soviet Russia. In Anthem, Equality never mentions a greater being until the end, when he has escaped society and figures things out on his own.
Even though these societies relate, there are some differences. First of all, I think that Rand made the society in Anthem into a much harsher representation of Soviet Russia. The people in Anthem don’t even have families. Their entire lives revolve around their jobs and their only time off is to go to the theater to see a show for a couple of hours. They are never given any alone time, time to think, and the government is completely against all advancement of knowledge. Also, food was rationed in Soviet Russia, as another way to make things “equal”. In Anthem, it seems like the government takes pretty good care of its people in this way, to ensure they are healthy enough to work and do their job to contribute to society. However, once they reach an old age, they are no longer of any use, so the government gets them out of the way.
The society of Soviet Russia and the one in Anthem were very oppressive. These totalitarian societies were very harsh and extremely cruel towards those they governed. We can only hope that the past does not repeat itself and that the future society described in Anthem does not come to fruition.



Works Cited

“Revolution Comes to Russia.” AP European History. 12 Dec. 2012.
Shmoop Editorial Team. "Anthem" Shmoop.com. Shmoop University, Inc., 11 Nov.
2008. Web. 21 Apr. 2013. <http://www.shmoop.com/anthem-ayn-rand/>.


 

No comments:

Post a Comment